When the closing bell rang on the floor of the London stock exchange on Friday 23rd September 2011, the FTSE 100 Index had dived 5.6%. In monetary terms, £75 Billion had been wiped off the value of Britain’s (now not so) Blue Chip companies.
European stocks did not fare much better. The DAX and CAC were hit hard. Gold was sold off heavily and investors fled to USD for safety. How did the media commentators get it all so wrong? Take Emmy award winning financial journalist Suze Orman, for instance. On 20th September she advised her Twitter followers (of which there are almost 1.2 Million) thus: “Are you all taking advantage of the fact that GOLD pulled back- GOLD not silver but GOLD should make up at least 10-20% of your portfolio”.
Even I, a relatively small time investor with a few hundred Twitter followers knew that she was, as we Brits say, talking bollocks. To that end I publically challenged her to a little wager, which she declined to accept!
So why do we pay such close attention to financial media commentators who won’t put their money where their mouths are? They clearly have very little clue about short to medium term market conditions. Whilst we spend all day living and breathing finance, they spend much of their time signing books and having make-up applied. Indeed I have long held the philosophy that if a full-time media personality tells me to buy Cable, for instance, I’ll sell it!
There are notable exceptions, not within the polished world of the full time on air personalities, but the working contributors one finds on the major news networks. Jonathan Heonig, for instance gives first class advice to FBN viewers.
Bottom line is this. If these on-air geniuses are so market-smart then why don’t they use their wisdom to trade full time and make 10X the income they make as jobbing reporters?
Investors who lost money after Orman’s investment advice should have just cause to sue her and her network.
